Cost Effectiveness of Residential Radon Remediation with Household Mobility
نویسندگان
چکیده
The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) estimates that exposure to residential radon causes 7,000 to 30,000 lung cancer deaths per year. The EPA has provided extensive technical analysis of and support for their recommended policy response of remediating all homes above a threshold level of radon, but these and other benefit-cost analyses typically do not consider many important dimensions of household heterogeneity, specifically residential mobility. We add to the literature on benefit-cost analysis by using agent based models that allow for heterogeneous benefits. Using this model, we re-examine the EPA’s recommendations for radon remediation. Since there is both a capital and an annual cost of radon remediation, many well informed households are better off not complying with the EPA’s recommendation. We find that most households are better of by not paying the annual cost of remediation and that only the least mobile households with smokers would undertake the capital cost of radon remediation in houses with very high radon concentrations. Since only a small fraction of the population values radon remediation, our model suggests that approximately 10% of the capital cost is likely to be capitalized into the resale value of the house. Erik Johnson Georgia Institute of Technology 221 Bobby Dodd Way, Atlanta, GA 30332 [email protected] Paul N. Courant University of Michigan 818 Hatcher Graduate Library South, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 [email protected] David Mendez University of Michigan 1415 Washington Heights; M3232 SPH II, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109 [email protected] Kenneth E. Warner University of Michigna 1420 Washington Heights; M3174, SPH II, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109 [email protected] Cost Effectiveness of Residential Radon Remediation with Household Mobility Erik P. Johnson, Paul N. Courant, David Mendez, Kenneth E. Warner
منابع مشابه
The cost-effectiveness of residential radon remediation programmes: assumptions about benefits stream profiles over time.
A recent cost-effectiveness analysis of a residential radon remediation programme considered and highlighted many areas of uncertainty in the parameters chosen for the analysis. One assumption not challenged in the study was the benefits stream profile adopted. There are several different ways of loading the benefits in terms of life years into the cost-effectiveness model and several of these ...
متن کاملEffects of residential mobility on individual versus population risk of radon-related lung cancer.
The U.S. Environment Protection Agency (EPA) does not consider the effects of normal patterns of residential mobility in estimating individual radon-related lung cancer risks. As a consequence, the EPA's population risk estimates may have little bearing on individual risks, and remediation of high-radon homes may have only small health benefits for the individual who remediate their homes. Thro...
متن کاملA cost-effectiveness analysis of domestic radon remediation in four primary care trusts located in Northamptonshire, UK.
The paper considers how primary care trusts (PCTs), which are relatively new organisations in the UK health service, might respond to the health hazards associated with radon in domestic properties. To this end, the cost-effectiveness of radon remediation programmes in four primary care trusts is calculated and compared with those of other interventions that can avert and treat lung cancer. The...
متن کاملA new methodology for cost-effectiveness studies of domestic radon remediation programmes: quality-adjusted life-years gained within primary care trusts in central England.
Radon is a naturally occurring radioactive gas, high levels of which are associated with geological formations such as those found in Northamptonshire and North Oxfordshire in the UK. The UK's National Radiological Protection Board have designated both districts as radon Affected Areas. Radiation levels due to radon, therefore, exceed 200 Bq m(-3), the UK's domestic Action Level, in over one pe...
متن کاملCost effectiveness analysis of radon remediation programmes.
The economic implications of regulations governing radon gas level identification and remediation in buildings are poorly understood, and attempts to address these issues have been criticised for lack of comparability. It is imperative therefore that a general model for the economic evaluation of radon remediation programmes is adopted to ensure comparability between studies and settings and to...
متن کامل